Some links included in this post may be affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission—at no extra cost to you—if you choose to purchase through them. I only share products I use, love, or believe in. Thank you for supporting my content and helping me keep the Ohana Getaways going strong!
Table of Contents
One of the first questions that comes up when I start planning a Walt Disney World vacation is where to stay.
And then comes the second question:
Is it actually worth paying more for a Moderate or Deluxe resort?
My answer is not automatically yes.
Disney has some beautiful Deluxe resorts. I love plenty of them. If someone would like to send me to the Polynesian for research purposes, I will make that sacrifice.
But a more expensive resort is not automatically a better decision for every family.
Sometimes I think upgrading is absolutely worth the money.
Sometimes I would rather see you keep the extra money for dining, another park day, flights, Lightning Lane, or whatever else matters more to your family.
The right answer depends on how you actually vacation.
First, What Is the Difference Between Value, Moderate, and Deluxe?
Walt Disney World Resort hotels are generally grouped into Value, Moderate, Deluxe, and Deluxe Villa categories.
Value resorts are usually the most budget-friendly Disney-owned options. They tend to have larger-than-life Disney theming, food courts, pools, and Disney transportation.
Moderate resorts usually add a little more space, more detailed theming, expanded dining options, and additional amenities.
Deluxe resorts generally offer premium locations, more dining options, more elaborate pools and grounds, and in many cases easier access to at least one theme park.
But those descriptions only tell you what the resorts have.
The better question is whether your family will actually USE what you’re paying extra for.
A Value Resort Can Be the Right Choice
If your plan is to leave your room early every morning, spend most of the day in the parks, come back exhausted, shower, sleep, and repeat…
I have a hard time telling you that you absolutely need to spend hundreds more per night on your hotel.
You are barely there.
Disney Value resorts can make a lot of sense for families who would rather put their vacation budget toward park tickets, food, experiences, or simply keeping the overall trip cost under control.
They can also be fun.
Value does not mean miserable.
Some families love the bold Disney theming, especially with younger kids.
And depending on the resort, transportation can still be very convenient. Disney’s Pop Century and Art of Animation, for example, have Skyliner access.
If the room is mostly where you’re sleeping, paying more simply because someone on the internet says Deluxe resorts are “better” probably isn’t necessary.
When a Moderate Resort Starts Making Sense
Moderate resorts are often where I start looking when a family wants the resort to feel like more than just a place to sleep but does not necessarily want Deluxe pricing.
Maybe you are building a resort afternoon into your trip.
Maybe you want a slightly calmer atmosphere.
Maybe the pool matters.
Maybe you want different restaurant choices nearby.
Maybe you are staying long enough that your family will actually spend time at the resort instead of treating every day like a park marathon.
This is where I start comparing the actual price difference rather than automatically choosing based on category.
If moving from Value to Moderate costs a manageable amount for your dates and gives you things your family genuinely cares about, I may absolutely recommend it.
If the upgrade adds thousands of dollars to the vacation and nobody cares about the difference?
Probably not.
Deluxe Can Be Worth It for Location Alone
This is one of the biggest reasons I will sometimes recommend paying more.
Location can change the entire trip.
Being able to walk to a theme park or use the monorail instead of relying on a bus can be extremely valuable for certain families.
Imagine you have small kids.
You spend the morning at Magic Kingdom.
Everyone has reached the stage where nobody should be making major life decisions.
Being able to walk back to your resort or quickly hop on the monorail for a break can feel very different from waiting for a bus and then traveling farther across Walt Disney World.
The same applies to families traveling with grandparents, mobility considerations, or anyone who knows midday breaks will be a regular part of the trip.
You’re not just paying for nicer landscaping.
Sometimes you’re paying for convenience.
And convenience has value.
Deluxe Is Also More Valuable When You Use the Resort
I would think very differently about a Deluxe resort for a three-night park-heavy trip than I would for a seven-night vacation with rest days built in.
If you are planning pool time, resort meals, slower mornings, afternoon breaks, or a full day away from the parks, the resort itself becomes part of what you’re buying.
Then amenities matter more.
A nicer pool matters more.
Restaurants matter more.
Location matters more.
The atmosphere matters more.
This is why I don’t like answering “Is Deluxe worth it?” without knowing how the family plans to travel.
Worth it for what?
Your Family’s Ages Matter
Disney resort priorities change as your kids get older.
When mine were younger, proximity, naps, transportation, and how complicated it was to get everyone from Point A to Point B mattered a lot.
Teenagers may care more about food, pools, transportation, and being able to move around with a little more independence.
And adults traveling without small children may care more about the resort experience itself.
There isn’t one resort category that automatically works best at every stage.
The hotel should fit the family taking this particular trip.
Transportation Can Be Worth Paying For
Before upgrading solely because one hotel looks prettier, look at how you’ll get around.
Disney transportation is included for Disney Resort guests, but not every resort has the same options.
Some rely primarily on buses.
Some have Skyliner access.
Some use boats.
Several Deluxe resorts have monorail access or are within walking distance of a park.
If your family hates waiting for buses, that information matters.
If your family could not care less and will happily hop on whatever gets you there, it may not be worth paying considerably more.
Again, the answer comes back to the people taking the trip.
Do Not Forget About the Total Vacation Budget
This is where I want to look beyond the nightly hotel rate.
What is the total difference over your entire stay?
An additional $100 a night sounds very different on a three-night trip than it does on an eight-night trip.
And what would you do with that money otherwise?
Would it pay for airfare?
Would it allow you to stay another night?
Would you rather have Park Hopper tickets?
Would you rather do a special meal or experience?
Would you simply feel better knowing the vacation did not cost another $1,500?
There is value in that too.
The goal is not to squeeze every possible upgrade into the budget.
It is to spend money on the things that will actually improve YOUR vacation.
When I Would Personally Pay More
I would seriously consider upgrading when:
The location saves the family significant time or transportation hassle.
We know they will take midday breaks.
The resort is an important part of the vacation.
The family is staying long enough to enjoy the amenities.
The pool or dining matters to them.
The price difference is reasonable for the dates.
Someone in the family has a specific need that makes the resort significantly easier.
Those are real reasons.
“Everyone in the Facebook group says this hotel is amazing” is not quite as persuasive.
When I Would Save the Money
I would probably stick with the more affordable option when:
The family will spend nearly every waking hour in the parks.
The upgrade would stretch the budget.
The kids do not care where they stay.
Transportation differences are not important to the family.
The trip is short.
The additional amenities are things nobody plans to use.
Or the less expensive resort is simply the one the family likes better.
You do not get extra Disney points for spending the most money.
So, Which Disney Resort Category Should You Choose?
Start with your actual vacation.
How many days are you staying?
How much time will you spend at the resort?
Do you take midday breaks?
Who is traveling?
How important is transportation?
What does your family care about?
And what does the price difference look like for your specific dates?
Then choose.
Sometimes that will be a Value resort.
Sometimes Moderate is the sweet spot.
And sometimes I will absolutely tell you the Deluxe resort is worth paying for.
My job is not to automatically find you the most expensive hotel.
It is to help you figure out which one makes sense for your family.
If you’re planning a Walt Disney World vacation and don’t want to compare every resort yourself, tell me who’s going, your dates, budget, and what matters most to your family.
I’ll help narrow it down.
Ready to start planning? lindseypierce.com/quote
Read more:
